Eleven agencies signed up through your busiest social channel in 2025. By August, eight of them had stopped paying. Four came through a comparison post you almost deleted, and all four paid again in December. The first source looks like the winner on a signup count. The second one is the one still paying you.
That's the point of this review. A source is worth the agencies it brought who still pay, not the number who clicked a signup button once. So you'll rank every 2025 referral source by how many of its agencies are still paying their partner subscription in January 2026. Then you'll set your affiliate marketing goals for 2026 on the recurring commission that's still active. Next year's hours go to the content and channels that bring agencies who stay.
We're using SendTo's affiliate programme as the worked example, because it's ours and we know every term. This is written on Friday 2 January 2026, for a desk session you can finish in one sitting. Every step gives you the action, what you should see when it's done, and the mistake that skews the numbers at that point.
By the end of this review you will have a ranked source list and a 2026 target built on agencies who stay
The first working week of January is the right time for this. Your December commission has just landed, the year is closed, and nothing new has muddied the picture yet. Give it two or three hours and you'll walk away with three things you can use straight away.
- One spreadsheet that ranks every 2025 source by the agencies it brought who are still paying, with a retention rate next to each.
- One figure for the recurring commission still active each month, split by source and totalled.
- Quarterly targets for 2026, written as active paying agencies and active monthly commission at the end of each quarter.
Those three outputs turn affiliate marketing goals for 2026 from a hopeful signup number into a plan you can check every quarter. Before you start, pull everything into one folder so you're not hunting mid-task.
- Your SendTo affiliate dashboard export, covering every referral from 1 January to 31 December 2025.
- A list of every link and campaign tag you used in 2025, with where each one lived (which post, video, email, community thread or call).
- Your 2025 PayPal statements, showing each monthly commission payment.
- Your publishing calendar, or at least the dates each main piece of content went live.
Step 1: Credit each 2025 referral to the source that earned the first click
Start with the export. Open it, add a column called Source, and give every referred agency exactly one entry in it. Keep the source specific. "Blog" is too broad to act on. "Comparison post, white-label email platforms" tells you what to write more of. The same goes for "Email", which should become the actual send or sequence, and "Social", which should name the channel.
The rule that decides the credit is ours, so here it is plainly. SendTo attribution lasts 90 days from the first click, and the first touch wins. If an agency owner clicked your September walkthrough video, then clicked a link in your newsletter in November, then signed up in early December, the referral belongs to the September video. The newsletter didn't earn it under our rules, even though it was the last thing they saw.
That's why your publishing calendar matters here. Line up each referral's first click date against when your content went live. A December signup often traces back to something published in September or October. If you ran follow-up sequences to warm leads, they'll often show up as touches inside the window rather than as the first click, and that's fine. You're recording what earned the referral, not grading the sequence.
What you should see at the end is one row per referred agency, each with one source. No blanks, no "various", no rows with two sources split by a slash.
The mistake to avoid is crediting the last thing the agency saw, or the channel you feel did the work. You'll be tempted to give credit to the podcast you loved recording. If the first tagged click came from a community post, the community post gets the row. Gut feeling is how a weak channel survives another year.
Step 2: Sort every referral into still paying, stopped paying, or never converted
Add a second column called Status. Each row gets one of three values, and the definitions need to be strict or the whole ranking wobbles.
- Still paying: the agency paid its partner subscription for December 2025 and hasn't cancelled as of 2 January 2026.
- Stopped paying: the agency paid at least one month in 2025 and then stopped, including agencies that are currently paused.
- Never converted: the agency signed up or started but never paid a partner subscription month.
What counts as retained, and how long does an agency need to stay before you count it? For this review, an agency is retained if it's in the Still paying group. That's it. But add a small flag column called New for any agency whose first paid month was November or December 2025. Those agencies count as still paying, yet they haven't been tested by time. Keep them in, and remember they're the least certain rows in the sheet.
What you should see is three clear groups, with a count of each for every source. A quick pivot table does this in a minute. Sources down the side, statuses across the top, count of agencies in the cells.
The mistake here is counting trials or signups as wins. Commission only comes from the months an agency pays its partner subscription, so a signup that never paid earned you nothing, and a signup that paid for two months and left earned you two months. Only paying agencies count. If you want the longer view of why agencies leave and what that does to an affiliate's income, our piece on affiliate churn covers it. For this review, you only need the status.
Step 3: Rank sources by agencies still paying, not by first conversions
A few sources bring in most of your retained agencies. That's what the 80/20 rule looks like in affiliate work, and this step is where you find out which few they are. For each source, add two numbers. Converted is the number of agencies that paid at least one month (Still paying plus Stopped paying). Retention rate is Still paying divided by Converted. In a spreadsheet, if Converted is in column C and Still paying in column D, the formula is =D2/C2, formatted as a percentage.
Then sort by Still paying, highest first, and use retention rate to break ties. Here's how the sheet looked for Maya, a freelance email consultant who promoted SendTo across six sources in 2025.
| Source | Converted | Still paying | Stopped paying | Retention rate | Rank note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Setup walkthrough video | 6 | 5 | 1 | 83% | Ranked |
| Comparison post, white-label email platforms | 5 | 4 | 1 | 80% | Ranked |
| Newsletter sequence to retainer clients list | 7 | 4 | 3 | 57% | Ranked |
| Social channel posts | 11 | 3 | 8 | 27% | Ranked |
| Agency community thread | 4 | 1 | 3 | 25% | Ranked |
| Podcast guest spot | 2 | 2 | 0 | 100% | Too early to rank |
Look at what happens to the social channel. On first conversions it was Maya's top source by a distance, with eleven agencies. On agencies still paying it drops to fourth, behind a video and a comparison post that converted at half the pace. The comparison post brought only five agencies all year, and four of them are still paying. That slow post is worth more to her 2026 than the busy feed.
What you should see is a sorted list where your top three sources are ranked on agencies still paying, each with a rate beside it.
The mistake is ranking on percentages from tiny samples. The podcast spot shows 100%, which looks brilliant and means almost nothing. Two agencies is not a pattern. Any source with fewer than three conversions gets marked "too early to rank" and sits at the bottom of the sheet, unranked, until it earns more data. Three is a low bar on purpose. Even at three, one agency leaving swings the rate by a third, so read those rows with care.
Step 4: Measure the recurring commission each source still produces each month
Counts tell you which sources keep agencies. Commission tells you what those agencies are worth to you right now. Add a column called Monthly commission and fill it from your PayPal statements, using the actual commission line for each agency in your most recent payment.
Here are our terms, exactly. You earn 20% of the partner subscription each referred agency pays SendTo, every month it pays. Commission is paid monthly, by PayPal. You never earn a share of what that agency's own clients pay the agency. An agency that resells SendTo to forty clients at its own prices pays us the same partner subscription as one with four clients, and your commission follows the partner subscription only.
What you should see is a monthly active commission figure for each source, made by summing the Monthly commission column for its Still paying rows, and one total at the bottom. That total is your active recurring commission going into 2026. It's the base every target in Step 6 builds on.
The mistake is multiplying agency counts by a plan price you assume, or one you remember from a page you read last spring. Partner subscriptions differ and plans change, so an assumed figure drifts away from what you're actually paid. Use the PayPal lines. If you want to see the current plans, they're on our pricing page, but your review should rest on real payments, not list prices.
Step 5: Find out why the sources that keep agencies keep them
The ranking tells you which sources keep agencies. It doesn't tell you why. Take your top three retained sources and write two short lines for each, in a new tab. The first line says who the content reached. The second says what it promised them.
Be honest when you write those lines. "Agency owners" is too vague to use. "Agency owners already running email for retainer clients, who wanted to stop building it themselves" is something you can aim at again. For the promise, write what the viewer or reader was told they'd get, in the words the content actually used.
Here's what Maya wrote for her top three.
- Setup walkthrough video. Reached agency owners who had already decided to offer email to clients and wanted to see the first branded campaign built. Promised a client-ready campaign by the end of the video, with sending and domain warmup handled.
- Comparison post, white-label email platforms. Reached owners searching for a platform to resell under their own name. Promised a plain comparison of what each option covers, including where SendTo isn't the right fit.
- Newsletter sequence to retainer clients list. Reached her own consulting clients, agencies with monthly retainers. Promised a way to turn the email work they already did into a product with its own monthly fee.
A pattern shows up quickly. Content aimed at agencies with retainer clients, honest demos and setup walkthroughs brings buyers who already have a use for the platform on the day they sign up. They aren't curious. They have clients waiting. Our piece on agencies on retainer models explains why that group stays longer, so we won't repeat it here.
What you should see is three pairs of lines, and at least one phrase repeated across them. In Maya's case it was "already sells email to clients". That phrase is your 2026 brief.
The mistake is copying the format and missing the audience. Maya's walkthrough worked because of who it reached and what it promised, not because it was a video. A second video aimed at people who are curious about email marketing will look like a top source and behave like her social feed. An AI writing tool can tidy your notes into a brief, and it's fine for that, but it can't tell you why an agency stayed. Your comments, replies and call notes can.
Step 6: Set affiliate marketing goals for 2026 on active recurring commission, not signups
Your 2026 target starts from what's already paying you, not from zero. Build it in three parts. Start with active agencies on 1 January. Take away the losses you can expect, using your 2025 retention rate. Then add the new retained agencies you'll need each quarter to reach the number you want.
Maya's sheet makes the maths easy to follow. She went into 2026 with 19 agencies still paying, from 35 that converted in 2025. That's a retention rate of 54%, so 46% stopped. Applying the 46% to her base of 19 gives about 9 expected losses across 2026, or roughly 2 a quarter. That's a cautious figure. Agencies that have already stayed a year tend to leave less often than new ones, but it's safer to plan on the rate you've seen than the one you hope for.
She set an end-of-year target of 24 active agencies. Working it through, 19 minus 9 losses leaves 10, so she needs 14 new retained agencies across the year. She then spread them unevenly, to match the calendar in Step 7.
- End of Q1, 31 March: start 19, lose 2, add 4 new retained, finish at 21 active agencies.
- End of Q2, 30 June: start 21, lose 2, add 2 new retained, finish at 21.
- End of Q3, 30 September: start 21, lose 3, add 3 new retained, finish at 21.
- End of Q4, 31 December: start 21, lose 2, add 5 new retained, finish at 24.
For the commission side, take your Step 4 total and divide it by your active agencies to get your average active commission per agency. Multiply each quarter's agency target by that average. Because the average comes from your real PayPal lines, the target follows what you're actually paid, not a list price.
What you should see is four checkpoints, each written as active paying agencies and active monthly commission at the end of the quarter. That's what affiliate marketing goals for 2026 look like when they're built to be checked.
The mistake is one annual signup number that ignores losses. "Thirty signups in 2026" sounds ambitious, but if a third never pay and half of the rest leave, it hides a flat year. A target is a plan for where your effort goes. It's not a forecast, and nothing in this review promises a result. It tells you early, at each quarter end, whether the plan is working.
Step 7: Move effort to the sources that keep agencies and fit the 2026 calendar
Hours are the only thing you really control, so this step is about where they go. Look at the bottom of your ranked list and pause or cut the sources with low retention and a full year of data. For Maya, that meant the social channel at 27% and the community thread at 25%. She kept one social post a week to point at new videos and stopped writing for the feed itself. The hours went to a second walkthrough and two more comparison posts, aimed at agencies that already sell email to clients.
Then plan those hours around the year. Interest in email marketing peaks in January, November and December, and it's lowest in June. That's why Maya's quarterly targets aren't even. January is happening now, so anything you publish or refresh this month meets agency owners while they're planning their year.
The 90-day first-touch window changes how you use the rest of the year. A click on content published in early September stays credited to you until early December, and a click in early October runs into early January. So content that goes live by early autumn can earn first clicks that convert during the Q4 peak. Use the quiet weeks around June to make that content, not to chase signups that aren't there. Our guide to seasonal market shifts covers keeping existing commission steady through those weeks.
What you should see is a 2026 calendar with fewer sources on it, more hours against your top three, and your main pieces dated to go live in January and by early autumn.
The mistake is cutting a source on one bad quarter or a tiny sample. Only pause sources that had at least three conversions and a full year to show their pattern. A "too early to rank" source like Maya's podcast spot gets one more test, not a cut.
Check the review worked by reconciling it with your PayPal statements
A spreadsheet that doesn't match your payments is a guess. Before you close the file, run three checks.
- Your total active commission from Step 4 matches the commission in your most recent PayPal payment.
- Every referral has exactly one source, with no blanks, no "various" and no split rows.
- No source is ranked on fewer than three conversions.
If the total doesn't match, the gap almost always comes from one of three places. First, look for referrals outside the 90-day window. If an agency's first tagged click came more than 90 days before signup, it isn't credited to you under our rules, so take it out of your sheet. Second, look for agencies that paused and came back. One might sit in Stopped paying while it's paying again, or the other way round. Move it to the status that matches your latest payment. Third, look at your Untagged rows. A bare link still earns commission when it's yours, but you can't tell which source earned it.
Fix those links now, while 2026 is quiet. Give every link in your posts, videos, sequences, slides and replies its own campaign tag, and add each one to your link list with where it lives. Next January's review will take half the time.
Last, set four calendar reminders, one for the first working week after each quarter ends. At each one, rerun Steps 2 to 4 and compare the result with that quarter's checkpoint. It takes under an hour once the sheet exists. If you're behind, you'll know in April, not next January.
That's the whole review. You now know which 2025 sources brought agencies who stay, what they're paying you each month, and where your hours go in 2026. If you're not promoting SendTo yet, you earn 20% of the partner subscription of every agency you refer, every month it pays, paid monthly by PayPal, with 90-day first-touch attribution.
Join the programme, get your links, and tag every one from day one so your first review is easy.
Join the SendTo affiliate programme


