AI Overviews won't hit every page on a small business website equally. They take clicks first from simple "what is" and "how do I" questions that one paragraph can answer. They mostly leave local, comparison and ready-to-buy searches alone, because those searchers still have to pick someone. That's the Google AI Overviews small business traffic question answered in three sentences, and it's a calmer answer than the one going round.
It's Sunday 9 June 2024, a little under four weeks since the US rollout. Don't panic about one total traffic number. Sort your pages by intent first. Then move effort towards the searches that still need a click, make the informational pages you keep worth citing, and build an owned channel that no search box can summarise away. For a small business, that channel is email.
Below you'll find a way to watch the change yourself while hard data is thin, an intent audit you can run in an afternoon, a table showing what to do with each type of page, and practical fixes for local and comparison content. It's written for agencies, freelancers and owners who run marketing for florists, plumbers, electricians and salons.
AI Overviews take the easy questions first, and small business blogs are full of easy questions
Google announced AI Overviews at Google I/O on 14 May 2024 and switched them on in the US for signed-out searchers using English. They grew out of the Search Generative Experience, the test that had been running in Search Labs. An overview is a block of generated text at the top of the results. It answers the query directly and links to some of the pages it drew from.
Take two searches a heating engineer's site might rank for. "How long does a boiler service take" has one answer, usually somewhere between 30 and 60 minutes for a standard gas boiler. A paragraph delivers that. Once the searcher has read it at the top of the page, they've got what they came for and there's nothing left to click for.
"Boiler service near me" is a different search. The searcher doesn't want a fact. They want a person, a free slot and a price. A paragraph can't service their boiler. They still have to compare a few local firms, read some reviews and ring one, and that takes a click or a call.
That's why blogs are more exposed than service pages. Plenty of small business content was written to answer exactly the quick question, like "how often should you water an orchid" or "what does an RCD do". Those posts brought in visitors who rarely booked anything. That traffic is the first to go.
Four weeks in, the honest answer is that nobody can measure the loss precisely yet
Anyone quoting you a confident percentage drop right now is guessing. Search Console doesn't report AI Overview impressions or clicks separately. They're folded into the normal web search figures, so you can't filter for them. On top of that, overviews appear on some queries and not others, and they've changed since launch. The same search could show an overview one day and plain results the next, as anyone searching in the US could see.
Other things are moving at the same time, too. The March 2024 core update only finished rolling out in April. Seasonal demand shifts as well. A US florist's traffic falls after Mother's Day every year, and Mother's Day this year was 12 May, two days before the launch. Blame the overview for that dip and you'll fix the wrong thing. If you're an agency, we've covered the client reporting side of the May 2024 rollout separately.
You can still watch for the pattern yourself. The thing to look for is click-through rate falling on question searches while impressions and position hold steady. Here's the method we'd use.
- Open the Performance report in Search Console and add a query filter set to Custom (regex), using a pattern such as ^(what|how|why|when|can|does|is) to catch question-style searches.
- Set weekly date ranges starting with the week of 6 May, the week before launch, and note clicks, impressions, click-through rate and average position for each week.
- Run the same weeks with the filter flipped to exclude those words. That's your control group of non-question searches.
- Compare the two lines. Falling clicks with steady impressions and position on questions, while the control holds, is the closest thing to an overview signature you'll get.
Sort every page by intent before you rewrite anything
The overview risk depends on what the searcher wants, not on the page. So before anyone rewrites a word, put every page that gets search traffic into one of four buckets. The table shows each bucket with an example from a florist, plumber, electrician or salon.
| Intent type | Example query | Overview risk | What to do |
|---|---|---|---|
| Simple informational | how long do roses last in a vase (florist) | High | Lead with a direct answer so it's citable, link to a service, and offer a reason to subscribe |
| Complex or opinion informational | is a water softener worth it in a hard water area (plumber) | Medium | Add first-hand detail, photos, local conditions and the owner's own view |
| Comparison | balayage vs highlights for dark hair (salon) | Low to medium | Give a clear verdict, real price ranges and when the answer changes |
| Local or transactional | emergency electrician Leeds open now (electrician) | Low | Strengthen the business profile, reviews, hours and quote route |
Sort a typical florist or plumber site this way and the risk usually sits in a handful of blog posts, not in the service pages that bring in calls. That changes the conversation. You're not rebuilding a website. You're deciding what to do with eight or ten posts.
How to run the audit in an afternoon
You need Search Console, a spreadsheet and about three hours. The word rules are crude, and that's fine. They get you 80% of the way there, and you tidy up the rest by eye.
- Export three months of queries from the Performance report, with clicks and impressions, plus the page each one lands on.
- Add an intent column and tag by simple word rules. What, how, why and when go in simple informational. Best, vs, versus and worth go in comparison. Near me, a town name, price, cost, open, emergency and book go in local or transactional.
- Read through the simple informational rows and move anything that needs judgement into complex or opinion.
- Add a clicks-at-risk column. Count clicks on high-risk rows in full, medium-risk rows at half and ignore the rest.
- Sort by clicks at risk, group by landing page, and the top ten pages are your work list.
Local and transactional searches still need a human decision, so put your effort there
Someone typing "emergency electrician Leeds open now" has a tripped fuse box and a dark kitchen. No summary fixes that. They need to choose one firm and ring it. Run local service searches in the US this week and you'll typically still see the map listings and business results doing the work near the top. Nobody outside Google knows whether that will stay true, but for now these are the searches that still turn into calls.
The work here is unglamorous, and it pays off because it's the moment someone picks a firm. Check these five things for each client.
- Business profile: correct categories, a real service area, recent photos of jobs and vans, and posts that show you're active.
- Reviews: a steady flow, asked for after every job, with a short reply from the owner to each one.
- Service-area pages: one for each town you actually cover, with real jobs, typical call-out times and local detail, never the same page with the town name swapped.
- Opening hours: kept up to date, including emergency and bank holiday hours, on the profile and the site.
- Prices or a quote route: a from-price, a call-out fee, or at least a quote form that says when you'll reply.
Service pages should also answer the questions buyers ask before they ring, such as whether there's a call-out charge and how fast someone can arrive. Our guide to structuring FAQ answer blocks on service pages shows how to lay those out so both searchers and answer engines can read them.
Comparison content is the small business advantage that a summary cannot copy
"Repair or replace a 12-year-old combi boiler" doesn't have a single answer. Neither does "which wedding flowers last in July heat". Both need judgement, local knowledge and experience of doing the job. An overview can list the factors. It can't tell you that a florist who's done dozens of summer barn weddings has watched peonies droop before the speeches and now uses garden roses and lisianthus instead.
That owner's view is the part searchers click through for. The catch is that a page listing "factors to consider" throws it away. If your comparison post ends with "it depends on your needs", a summary can replace it. If it ends with a decision, it can't.
Write comparison pages in this order.
- Put the verdict in the first two sentences. For example, if the boiler is under ten years old and the repair is a single part, repair it.
- Say when the verdict flips, such as a failed heat exchanger on a boiler past 12 years.
- Use real numbers, like typical repair and replacement price ranges in your area and how long each job takes.
- Add the local detail only you know, from hard water in your postcode to which venues run hot in July.
- Sign it with the owner's name and how long they've done the work, with a photo from a real job.
There's a trade-off. These pages take longer to write than a quick-answer post, and they'll never pull the volume that "how long do roses last" once did. But the people who search them are a lot closer to booking, and they're the visitors worth keeping.
Become the source an overview cites, because a citation is the click that is left
An overview that answers the question still shows a handful of linked sources next to the text. Some searchers tap them to check the answer or read more. On a simple informational query, that link is the click that's left, so it's worth competing for.
Nobody outside Google knows exactly how sources are picked. The rules aren't public, and anyone selling a guaranteed citation is selling a guess. But four weeks of US results, and a year of the Search Labs test before that, point to some page traits that tend to show up.
- Direct answers high on the page: the answer in the first two sentences, before any background.
- Headings phrased as questions: the way people type them, such as "How long do roses last in a vase?"
- Specific figures: times, temperatures, price ranges and quantities, not "it varies".
- Named authors with real experience: the owner's name, their trade and how long they've done it.
- Current dates: a visible "updated" date, and content that really was updated.
Here's what that looks like on a florist's post. The old version opens with 200 words on the history of roses and gets to the answer halfway down. The rewrite opens with "Five to seven days, and up to ten if you recut the stems and change the water every two days." Underneath, a question heading asks why roses droop early, followed by the bent-neck explanation and a photo from the shop's own cold room. It's signed by the owner, who has run the shop for 14 years. It's the same post with the useful part moved to the top.
None of this is new advice, and that's reassuring. It lines up with what Google appears to value in the leaked search ranking documents that surfaced in late May, which seem to show signals about authors and clicks being stored, though how they're weighted is unknown. Overviews aren't the only answer box either. The same habits help with earning brand mentions in AI chatbot answers, where clear, attributed facts get repeated too.
The early mistakes in AI Overviews are a reason to publish expert, specific answers
In the last week of May, screenshots of odd overview answers spread widely. One suggested adding glue to pizza sauce to stop the cheese sliding off, which traced back to an old joke on a forum. Another treated a satirical article about eating rocks as health advice. Some of those screenshots turned out to be fake, but enough were real to show the problem. An overview can pull from jokes and thin forum posts when nothing better covers the question.
Within days, overviews stopped appearing on many of those queries, as anyone searching could see. A system that's just been publicly embarrassed will tend to lean on sources it can trust.
That's good news for a plumber who writes clearly about pressure relief valves, or a salon owner who explains patch tests properly. Accurate, specific content signed by someone who does the work is exactly what a cautious system wants to cite. Vague posts with no author look much like the forum threads it's trying to avoid.
Search traffic you rent can shrink overnight, and an email list you own cannot
Every visit from search depends on a results page you don't control. That's the real lesson of the Google AI Overviews small business traffic story. Some pages will lose clicks this year whatever you do, and they won't be the last change to the results page. An email list is different. Nobody can put a summary between you and your subscribers, and a list of 600 local customers doesn't change when the results page does.
So every informational visitor who still clicks through should get a reason to subscribe, and it should match the post they're reading. A heating engineer's post on boiler pressure offers a pre-winter boiler checklist, emailed every October. A florist's vase-life post offers a reminder before Valentine's and Mother's Day pre-orders close. An electrician's rewiring guide ends with a quote form that signs the visitor up for a follow-up a week later. Each offer gets a reader a step closer to booking.
Don't delete the blog posts flagged as high risk in your audit. They still answer real questions your customers ask, and that makes them good email content. A single "how long do roses last" post becomes a care-tips email, a seasonal reminder and a short series for new subscribers. Our guide on turning one blog post into a month of emails shows eight ways to do it.
SendTo's signup forms are protected against bots and can sit on the site or a hosted landing page, with optional double opt-in for clients who want a confirmed consent record. Write a short campaign brief, and SendTo designs the HTML email from it and the client's brand preset in seconds. Reports leave out opens triggered by security scanners, so the open figures you show a client are human opens, not bot traffic.
What agencies and affiliates should tell clients this month
A client whose traffic dipped after mid-May wants to know two things. Is it the overviews, and what are you doing about it? The honest answer to the first is "partly, maybe, and we're measuring it". The second deserves a plan with dates on it. Here's the one we'd run over the next 30 days.
- Baseline the data: set up the question versus non-question comparison in Search Console, starting from the week of 6 May.
- Run the intent audit: tag three months of queries and list the ten pages with the most clicks at risk.
- Strengthen local and comparison pages: business profile, reviews, hours, quote routes and pages that give a verdict.
- Make the top informational pages citable: answer first, question headings, figures, a named author and an updated date.
- Add list capture: a matching signup offer on every at-risk post, and a first email ready to send.
If you're an agency, this is a retainer conversation, not a crisis call. The audit is a deliverable, the page work runs for months, and the email list gives the client something they own and see growing every month. If your clients are outside the US, you can run all five steps before overviews reach them, and that's an easy case to make.
If you're an affiliate, blogger or creator who recommends software, agencies are looking for owned-channel tools they can sell to clients right now. An email platform they can run under their own brand fits that conversation. For what SendTo costs agencies, send readers to the pricing page rather than quoting a figure.
If you write for agencies, SendTo's affiliate programme pays you 20% of the partner subscription of every agency you refer, every month that agency pays it. You never get a share of what the agency's own clients pay them. Attribution lasts 90 days from the first click, the first touch wins, and commission is paid monthly by PayPal.
Join the SendTo affiliate programme


